Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear... For anyone still wondering what's really behind the SEIU mask, here's an ugly glimpse courtesy of Local 26 President
Javier Morillo-Alicea, consultant
Jo-Ann Mort, and repeat Perez star PR hack
Michelle Ringuette!


In the process of sending a "spam" email (their words not Perez's) to academics who signed an open letter about SEIU's raid on UNITE HERE, it seems these three stooges accidentally included some emails that were less ready for prime time!-------
[Dear academic/s]:
I received today the “Open Letter” you mailed to me regarding the dispute between my union, SEIU, and UNITE-HERE. I believe you should have received a response that rebuts some of the claims in that letter from SEIU. I have included it below in case you have not seen it.
I did want to reach out to you directly and thank you for taking the time to write. As a former historian who left the world of academia because I was frustrated by the insular nature of the U.S. academic world, I am always happy to see university professors engaging with the world of organizing, politics, and policy. I mean that sincerely – I truly believe that our country would be a much better place if the world of talented researchers, thinkers, and writers were in constant, vibrant communication with the Labor Movement.
I am, of course, nonetheless disappointed in your letter not because I feel you should not be engaged in debates going on in the labor movement -- again, I applaud that – but because you and the other academic signatories to that letter, I believe, signed onto a set of arguments without doing some of the research and fact-checking you require of yourselves when producing work in your own fields. I won’t provide an extensive “our side of the story” in this email; the letter below addresses some of the more important aspects of our view of the dispute.
I will say, however, that I am honestly saddened that, even though in your letter you and your colleagues proclaim yourselves as “sharing SEIU’s progressive ideals” and as having “marched with its janitors, security officers, and nursing home workers,” that you would not pay those workers the respect they deserve by talking to them, to their union, about this situation before deciding that this was a simple story of bad guys and good guys, with our member-driven union in the role of the villain. As a historian whose work intersects the histories of race, gender, and the social constructions that create them, I am certain you are aware that rarely is historical reality as simple as a story of heroes and villains.
Finally, I want to say that I have taken the time to write this out of respect for who you are and what you do. Although I am no longer a historian, I am w ho I am today because of the work I did as a researcher, writer, and teacher. I write in the spirit of opening a dialogue that could avoid misunderstandings such as this one and which, much more importantly, can bring us together to do the important work we all believe in: creating a world with more justice for everyone.
Best Regards,
Javier Morillo-Alicea
President
SEIU Local 26
July 23, 2009
Dear Professor ******:
For the past several months, the dispute between UNITE HERE and Workers United/SEIU has consumed attention and resources at a time when workers all over the US and Canada need us to do everything we can to fight for them. It is clear this conflict is helping employers and hurting hardworking women and men. This must not continue.
Recently, you signed a letter weighing in on this matter. We are concerned that you may not have been told all the facts, so we want to share some background with you.
SEIU and Workers United have repeatedly called for UNITE HERE to join us in putting the interest of all our members first by resolving the issues between our unions. We must bring this conflict to a swift resolution for the sake of the workers.
As you may be aware, there have been a series of accusations and mischaracterizations made about SEIU by UNITE HERE over the past few months. SEIU called for a “cease fire” back in April, and we honored our commitment to détente. We have ceased all hostilities and incursions on UNITE HERE locals. However, last week at UNITE HERE’s convention, President John Wilhelm used a statement of solidarity condemning inter-union raiding signed by 15 leaders in the labor movementa letter we would have signed ourselvesto attack SEIU. President Wilhelm was quoted in the New York Times accusing SEIU of trying to “hijack” his union. He has mobilized individuals such as your self to sign on to general statements for his political use. And recently, he has made very public and untrue allegations of “raiding” activity despite refusing to submit evidence and engage in Change to Win’s procedures to resolve charges of raiding.
If John Wilhelm truly believes that SEIU is engaged in “raiding” activity, why will he not bring evidence or charges forward for a hearing?
There should be no confusion regarding SEIU's and Workers United’s position regarding UNITE HERE, but we will again make clear where we stand:
- SEIU has accepted the framework proposed by UFCW President Joe Hansen, and we stand ready to let President Hansen arbitrate this dispute. SEIU would honor the results of binding arbitration.
- SEIU accepts that hotels and gaming are the core jurisdiction of UNITE HERE, and we accept Joe Hansen's recommendation on food service being a core jurisdiction for SEIU. We have said to President Hansen and President Wilhelm that SEIU is not interested in raiding UNITE HERE members or organizing hotel or gaming workers generally. Both UNITE HERE and SEIU in previous discussions with Joe Hansen made requests for limited exceptions in each other's jurisdictions based on unique circumstances. SEIU believes that the arbitrator should develop a principle that applies equally to these disputed food service and hospitality workers and we should all live by the results.
- SEIU is not raiding UNITE HERE, and UNITE HERE must end its attacks on Workers United/SEIU and its raids on our members. SEIU called for a "cease fire" last April and we have honored our commitment. However, while we stood down, UNITE HERE escalated its strategy of attacking Workers United members and leaders, interfering with bargaining, and asking employers to escrow dues. For example:
- UNITE HERE organizers have been attacking California laundry shops since December 2008. While thousands of California laundry workers are fighting right now for strong contracts for themselves and their families, employers like ARAMARK are using UNITE HERE's interference to refuse to schedule bargaining dates. Please see Attachment #1 for actual leaflets distributed by UNITE HERE.
- UNITE HERE has contacted more than 1,600 Workers United Employers and urged them to escrow dues and deny access to union representatives. At Atrium Windows in Texas, the company used this to deny manufacturing workers access to health and safety records that workers need to protect themselves from unsafe working conditions. Please see Attachment #2 for letters sent by UNITE HERE asking for employers to escrow dues and cease bargaining efforts with Workers United.
- UNITE HERE is sending organizers into Workers United locals to disrupt bargaining. In Philadelphia, 2,500 Workers United members who provide school breakfast and lunch to students cannot get the school district to negotiate with them despite the fact that their contract has expired because UNITE HERE sent in 20 organizers to challenge their rights to bargain. Please see Attachment #3 to read a letter from the Philadelphia School District explaining its decision to escrow dues.
- UNITE HERE has encouraged employers to stop bargaining for first contracts at newly organized workplaces. At the Courtyard Marriott Niagara, where a worker had been fired for organizing, workers are still waiting for their chance to bargain a first contract after John Wilhelm wrote to the newly organized hotel and told the employer to stop bargaining. Please see Attachment #4 to read a letter from UNITE HERE Local 274 instructing a Workers United employer to stop negotiations with "SEIU's Workers United."
This cannot and should not continue. Every moment we spend fighting one another is a moment that we are not doing everything we can to:
- bring strange bedfellows like Wal-Mart to the table to deliver bold healthcare reform,
- save workers' jobs,
- fight unscrupulous employers like Bank of America,
- challenge the Chamber of Commerc e for its anti-worker positions, and
- stand for justice for immigrants in this country.
We are in the midst of the greatest economic catastrophe any of us has ever witnessed. Hardworking women and men who were struggling before the global financial crisis are taking a hit that will leave its mark long after the economy recovers. Our members’ hard-won gains – their healthcare, their pensions, their very jobs -- are now imperiled by external forces beyond their control. Unscrupulous employers are undercutting wages and benefits and threatening workers who speak out. And at a moment of promise in Washington, our well-funded and highly motivated opposition is gearing up for a fight to the finish.
We have spent our lifetimes working to give hardworking women and men their shot at the American Dream. The opportunities before us in Washington and around the country give us a chance right now to transform our national healthcare system. To make sure our members are part of the economy recovery. To pass the Employee Free Choice Act. In stead, we are at risk of watching everything we have accomplished become undone.
We simply cannot afford to let this happen to our members.
We have asked President Wilhelm to meet with us to end this conflict so that we can all move forward and be part of the solution as we rebuild our national economy. It is time for us to settle the dispute between UNITE HERE and Workers United/SEIU.
In coming days, we will share with you the letters of numerous leaders from the labor and social justice communities so that you might learn more about this dispute. We thank you for your concern and interest, and we hope you will ask UNITE HERE to end this war so we can focus our attentions on winning healthcare reform, employee free choice, comprehensive immigration reform and economic justice for hardworking women and men.
In solidarity,
Andy Stern
President, Service Employees International Union
Bruce Raynor
President, Workers United
Michelle A. Ringuette
202 730 7234 o
202 341 7057 m
www.seiu.org
-----
From:
Javier Morillo JMorillo@seiu26.orgSent:
Thursday, July 23, 2009 12:18 PMTo:
Jo-Ann Mort; Michelle Ringuette; Jo-Ann MortSubject:
RE: would love to touch base with you So here's my thought -- in addition to the general info spam they'll be receiving from now, I suggest we send to each of these academics a brief communication that;
- Shames them just a little bit for signing onto something without knowing all the facts - subtly, of course, while also talking about the productive relationship SEIU and the labor movement have had and should have with academia. I can work on that in a way that also makes the point that theory and praxis can coexist but only when there is open, honest communication (Nothing guilt-trips an academic more than reminding them how isolated they are, in this country, from the world of policy, politics, and activism. It's why I left).
- Gives a few key facts. I like today's letter from Andy to Willhelm because it hits directly to the charges in their open letter.
- Most importantly, I think we should invite them to something. We say something like "we have members and leaders across the country. Please give us the opportunity to talk with you about the issues your letter brings up as well as our broader concerns about20the labor movement." We can offer a variety of venues -- one on one meetings, conference calls, etc.
Then we organize these meetings. I do think it's important that we dedicate the time and energy to this. Get leaders and members from each state to volunteer to hold the meetings that are requested (I actually doubt few will take us up on it). It would be more work on the front end, but especially for the more prominent names maybe we have this communication signed by leaders and members from their state.
What do you think?
javier
-----Original Message-----
From:
Jo-Ann Mort joannmort@mac.comSent:
Thu 7/23/2009 7:12 AMTo:
Michelle Ringuette; Jo-Ann Mort; Javier MorilloSubject:
Re: would love to touch base with youI still think we sadly need to target Nelson in a positive way-most of these academics really are not worth it-but spamming them sounds like what they deserve!!
On 7/23/09 8:07 AM, "Michelle Ringuette" Michelle.Ringuette@seiu.org
wrote:And just to add in here, last night we discussed setting a few workers loose on people and lettling them call some of the academics. I know these aren't high value targets, but I firmly believe people shouldnot be permitted to do drive bys. They are all getting a letter this am and they all bought spot on our spam list.
Michelle A. Ringuette
Service Employees International Union
202 730 7234 w
202 341 7057 m
-----Original Message-----
From:
Jo-Ann Mort joannmort@me.comSent:
Thu 23-Jul-09 3:51 AMTo:
Javier MorilloCc:
Michelle RinguetteSubject:
would love to touch base with youhey Javier,
I am in Israel until next week but I am also working for SEIU while here. Michelle mentioned that you would like to help out re the academic/lefty mess re WU and SEIU, etc-i would love that!! I can call you from Israel if you want to talk or we can talk on email. I would like to start with you writing something that i can place and then, maybe we should think about you and a couple of other SEIU/WU leaders starting to meet with academics and others on the left to talk about moving forward-in a serious fashion. I just went through that list of 200 academics on the most recent letter and most of them are labor notes types-the ones I picked out whom we need to reach out to are Nelson Lichtenstein (for better or worse...), Jack Metzgar, who is a friend of mine and Mark Levinson's but has been hard on this topic , Andrew Ross, whom I already emailed and Andrew has worked very closely with UNITE in the past on sweatshops, and Jennifer Klein who is close to Nelson I know-and I know you talked to her-she is also a former student of Josh Freeman's- and why Alice Kessler Harris is on this list I don't know-we need to get to her too-
look forward to working on this with you.
best,
jo-Ann
Jo-Ann Mort
joannmort@me.com
Israel phone: (0)547-269-886
US phone: 718-954-0352
skype: jomort
-----
I wouldn't bother inviting anyone to anything if I were you Javier!